The bounty sold at Larsen’s is literally right off the boats, which pull up behind the small cottage with an azure-blue door. Technically a retail fish store, Larsen’s also sells homemade chowders and crab cakes, and they’ll boil lobsters for you. Prepare to wait if you arrive during peak hours, and BYOB. There’s no seating in the store, but dining alfresco on the Menemsha docks or on the beach is one of the most beloved island experiences.