Company of the Cauldron

Tucked off a cobblestoned street in a shingled, ivy-covered cottage, Company of the Cauldron is one of Nantucket’s most beloved restaurants. Every night a new, three-course prix-fixe menu is featured, highlighting local ingredients and seasonal produce. Locals in the know come on Mondays for Lobster Night, when each course offers a creative twist on classic lobster dishes. Dark wooden beams, softly lit candles and the melodious sounds of a harp create a romantic atmosphere.