La Ana de Cofresi

The mural adorning the walls of La Ana de Cofresi tells the story of Roberto Cofresi, a Puerto Rican pirate known for his altruism and charity, and his ship ‘La Ana.’ Fishing nets and buoys separate the dining area from the kitchen and El Bohio beach bar is set in the sand. The bar and restaurant along with the adjacent hotel have been owned by a local family since their inception in the 1960s, and remain local favorites. The Bohio’s “Pirate Special” cocktail, which consists of several different types of alcohol and is served in a coconut with a straw in it, claims international fame. Even if the campy décor and local infamy aren’t your thing, know that their mofongo, a traditional Puerto Rican dish prepared with fried then mashed plantains and meat, is one of the best on the island. The place may be tricky to find, so get specific directions from your hotel.